One verdict, shown two ways.
The 0–10 scale
TPCR scores films and TV out of 10, with decimal scores for a more precise verdict. These bands explain the scale; the score remains the named reviewer’s opinion.
- 10Masterpiece
- An exceptional work that earns our strongest recommendation.
- 9–9.9Outstanding
- A standout achievement with very little holding it back.
- 8–8.9Excellent
- A strong recommendation: memorable, accomplished and rewarding.
- 7–7.9Good
- Plenty to appreciate, with some reservations.
- 6–6.9Above average
- More works than doesn’t, though the shortcomings are noticeable.
- 5–5.9Average
- A mixed experience: strengths and weaknesses compete.
- 4–4.9Below average
- Some worthwhile elements, but the problems outweigh them.
- 3–3.9Poor
- Significant shortcomings make it difficult to recommend.
- 0–2.9Very poor
- Very little works for the reviewer; the full review explains why.
What goes into a score
The review explains how the work comes together: its storytelling, direction, performances, cinematography, editing, sound and overall impact. Different films and shows have different aims, so these are considerations rather than a fixed points formula.
A comedy, a horror film and a quiet drama can succeed in very different ways. The written review gives the context that a number alone cannot.
Scores & gold stars
The gold stars are a visual version of the same score, shown out of five. An 8/10 fills four stars; a 7.5/10 fills three and three-quarter stars. They are not a second rating or an audience vote.
A score out of 10 is not a Rotten Tomatoes approval percentage or an IMDb audience average. Scores and viewing information on TPCR Movie Recs come from the sources identified there and are separate from TPCR’s own reviews.
Our opinion, explained
You don’t have to agree with a score to find the review useful. Read the reasoning, compare it with your own tastes and decide whether the film or show sounds right for you.
Our scores are not for sale. Relevant supplied access or sponsorship should be disclosed with the article. Read our editorial standards or contact TPCR with feedback.