Loading your next read…
Loading your next read…
s an ambitious film that largely achieves what it sets out to do. It presents Haymitch’s story as a tragedy and refuses to pretend that knowing he survives makes everything else easier to watch.
All images and videos are owned by Roadshow and Lionsgate
You go into The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping knowing Haymitch Abernathy survives. You know he eventually becomes the man who mentors Katniss Everdeen. What you might not be prepared for is how little comfort that knowledge actually provides.
This is not a film you walk out of feeling good. It is tragic, cruel and, at times, exhausting. But that is also what makes it effective. Rather than treating Haymitch’s story as a triumphant account of how a familiar character won the Games, it asks you to spend time with a young man who still has joy, potential and a life ahead of him. Then it shows you how little any of that matters to the Capitol.
There is a lot to admire here, particularly Joseph Zada’s phenomenal lead performance. There are also things I wish the film had handled differently, from its use of an impressive supporting cast to its almost relentless emotional pressure. Still, it knows exactly what kind of story it wants to tell, and it commits to it. Every Connection Feels Like Borrowed Time Directed by Francis Lawrence, Sunrise on the Reaping takes us back to the 50th Hunger Games, also known as the Second Quarter Quell. This time, the number of tributes is doubled, with four children taken from each district instead of two. At the center is a young Haymitch, played by Joseph Zada. tickets.hungergames.movie
That setup creates a particularly cruel relationship between the audience and the characters. We already know who survives, but there is still only one winner. Every time Haymitch gets close to someone, or the film gives us a reason to care about another tribute, that knowledge sits in the background.
Every new connection feels like it is on borrowed time.
Knowing the outcome does not remove the tension because you do not necessarily know how everything will happen. You can anticipate the broad direction without being prepared for the individual moments. I will not spoil those here, especially because some of the film’s heaviest emotional blows are best experienced without warning.
What stayed with me most was the contrast between the person Haymitch could have become and the situation he is forced into. He has so much going for him, and the Capitol simply does not care. The film makes that disregard feel personal rather than abstract. These are young people with lives, relationships and possibilities, reduced to participants in something horrific.
It is a tragedy first, and the film is stronger for understanding that.
Australian actor Joseph Zada has a considerable task taking on the younger Haymitch, a character audiences already associate so strongly with Woody Harrelson. AP News What makes his performance work is that the connection feels convincing without becoming the only thing you notice.
His Southern American accent is impeccable. That familiar sound is there, and it helps establish continuity between the two versions of Haymitch. But getting the voice right would mean very little if the emotional performance underneath it did not work.
Thankfully, Zada gives this role everything.
He makes you care about Haymitch as the young person in front of you, not simply as someone important to the franchise’s future. That distinction matters. The tragedy needs us to connect with the life he has now, rather than just wait for him to become the character we recognize.
When the film reaches its most emotionally demanding scenes, Zada fully commits. He is a strong reason those moments hit as hard as they do, and easily one of the film’s biggest highlights.
Mckenna Grace is also phenomenal as Maysilee Donner. tickets.hungergames.movie There is a toughness to this performance that I really enjoyed. I tend to associate Grace with warmer or more immediately approachable characters, so seeing her take on someone with a harder edge was a welcome change. She brings a different energy to the film, and it suits her.
Ben Wang is very good, too. While Zada was the standout for me, the younger cast gives the film a strong foundation, which is especially important in a story where becoming attached to people is part of what makes the experience so difficult.
The supporting cast is another major strength, although it also leads to one of my biggest frustrations.
Glenn Close plays Drusilla Sickle, District 12’s tribute escort, and is practically unrecognizable. ABC News She makes the character genuinely difficult to watch, and I mean that as a compliment. There is something so irritating and uncomfortable about her presence that you find yourself reacting to her almost immediately. Close understands exactly how unpleasant this character needs to be.
Jesse Plemons is a very good addition as Plutarch Heavensbee, while Kieran Culkin takes on Caesar Flickerman. AP News Plemons enhances the film whenever he is involved, and Culkin feels like an especially perfect choice. His performance reinforces why I consider him one of the best actors working today.
However, Ralph Fiennes’ President Snow and Elle Fanning’s Effie Trinket left me wishing the film had made more room for them. AP News
Snow feels severely underutilized. With Fiennes in the role, there is so much potential, and I wanted more of his presence throughout the story. The issue is not that he fails to make an impression. It is that the film does not give him enough opportunity to build on it.
Effie has a similar problem. Her involvement comes so late, really only arriving in the third act, that I kept thinking she could have been introduced earlier. Fanning is someone I wanted to spend more time with in this role, rather than feel we were only getting to her toward the end.
These are frustrations with how the film distributes its attention, not with the performances themselves. When you assemble a cast this strong, it is hard not to notice where opportunities feel underexplored. **
Visually, there is a lot to appreciate. The sets are great, and the arena’s forested landscapes and grassy surroundings look gorgeous. There were moments when I genuinely wanted to know where they had filmed so I could visit and explore the area myself, preferably without the Hunger Games part.
That beauty creates an uncomfortable contrast with what is happening. The setting can look inviting while the situation is anything but. It is an effective visual choice for a story that keeps reminding you how awful this entire spectacle is.
The score is strong as well, supporting the film’s tension and emotional weight. Together, the music and visuals help make this a compelling experience even when it is an unpleasant one.
The pacing is generally well judged. The film knows when to move quickly and when to slow down, particularly during its bigger emotional moments. Those scenes are allowed to play out rather than being hurried along.
But letting a painful moment breathe is not quite the same thing as giving the audience a break.
From the moment Haymitch is selected as a tribute, my stress level barely dropped. My heart was racing, and the film kept finding ways to push that tension further. Even when the action slows, the dread remains.
That is a strength, but it also becomes a limitation. I wanted a little more breathing room, not because the film needed to become cheerful, but because spending so much time under that pressure can be draining. It also feels slightly too long, although not to the point that the length seriously undermines the experience. **
The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping is an ambitious film that largely achieves what it sets out to do. It presents Haymitch’s story as a tragedy and refuses to pretend that knowing he survives makes everything else easier to watch.
Zada is phenomenal, Grace is a major highlight, and the supporting cast gives us plenty to appreciate, even when some of its biggest names deserve more screen time. The gorgeous settings and strong score add to an experience that is consistently engaging, if occasionally overwhelming.
Fans of The Hunger Games, whether through the films or the books, have plenty to connect with here. Readers I spoke with after the screening felt that, despite some omissions, the adaptation was broadly faithful. For anyone drawn to dystopian science fiction, there is also a compelling story here about young lives being treated as disposable.
I wish the film had given certain characters more room and its audience a few more chances to breathe. Those shortcomings keep it from reaching its full potential. But its commitment to the story, and the performances carrying it, are difficult to fault.
You know Haymitch is going to survive. Sunrise on the Reaping makes sure that knowledge never feels reassuring. That's why I give this film a solid 7.5/10.